In The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald presents identity as something that is carefully constructed, publicly performed, and ultimately unstable. Set in the 1920s, a decade defined by economic expansion and social aspiration, the novel reflects a society in which personal worth is increasingly measured through wealth, image, and success. Through Jay Gatsby, Fitzgerald explores how identity can be shaped by desire and perception rather than authenticity, revealing how easily it can collapse once the illusion is exposed.
From the beginning of the novel, Gatsby’s identity is closely tied to his environment. His mansion, an extravagant imitation of European architecture, functions less as a home than as a display. It exists to project power, wealth, and social belonging, suggesting that Gatsby’s identity itself is a performance designed to gain acceptance within the upper class. Fitzgerald reinforces this idea through colour symbolism during Gatsby’s parties, where yellow imagery dominates, a colour associated with wealth and nobility. Yet this association is subtly undermined when characters who genuinely belong to old money are described as golden instead. In this contrast, Fitzgerald exposes Gatsby’s status as imitation rather than authenticity.
The fragility of Gatsby’s constructed identity becomes clear after his death, when his once-impressive house is described as incoherent and empty. The physical decay of the mansion mirrors the collapse of Gatsby’s public persona, revealing that his carefully curated image lacked substance. Fitzgerald suggests that an identity built on appearance and social performance cannot survive without an audience to sustain it.
Although Gatsby initially appears to embody the American Dream through wealth and excess, Fitzgerald complicates this reading by revealing that Gatsby’s fortune is acquired illegally. This revelation destabilises the image of Gatsby as a self-made success and exposes the moral weakness of the dream itself. However, Fitzgerald goes further by suggesting that Gatsby is not truly motivated by wealth at all. Gatsby shows little interest in his possessions and is willing to abandon the lavish parties that define his public image once Daisy disapproves of them. His identity, therefore, is not grounded in material ambition but in romantic devotion.
Yet even Gatsby’s love is shaped by illusion. Daisy functions less as a real individual and more as an idealised symbol of status, belonging, and self-reinvention. Gatsby’s devotion to her is rooted in fantasy, and when Daisy ultimately rejects him, the upper class rejects the identity he has created for himself. The collapse of Gatsby’s dream thus becomes the collapse of “Jay Gatsby” as a social construct.
Fitzgerald further complicates identity through Nick Carraway’s narration. As an unreliable narrator, Nick filters Gatsby’s character through admiration and romanticism, shaping how the reader perceives him. Gatsby’s identity is therefore not only self-created but also narratively constructed. In the end, The Great Gatsby presents identity as something fragile, performative, and dependent on perception, an illusion sustained only as long as people are willing to believe in it.
All Things Biology 